The Bottlenecks of Social Development among the Marginalized Residents (An Empirical Analysis of the Causal and Background Conditions Among Marginalized Residents in Pak-Dasht and Qiyam-Dasht: A Data-Based Study) | ||
| فصلنامه برنامه ریزی توسعه شهری و منطقه ای | ||
| Article 6, Volume 8, Issue 27, December 2023, Pages 203-247 PDF (1.5 M) | ||
| Document Type: Research Paper | ||
| DOI: 10.22054/urdp.2023.70792.1495 | ||
| Authors | ||
| Abozar Qaseminejad* 1; Mohsen Shabestar2; Aliasqar Esmaeilzadeh3 | ||
| 1PhD of Welfare planning, Allameh Tabataba'i University, Tehran, Iran | ||
| 2PhD Candidate in urban planning, Allameh Tabataba’i University, Tehran, Iran | ||
| 3Assistant Professor of Social Pathology, Department of Alborz, Academic Center for Education, Culture and Research, Alborz, Iran | ||
| Abstract | ||
| In contemporary society, marginalization has emerged as a significant social issue, imposing formidable barriers to social development. Accordingly, this study aims to explore the causal and contextual factors contributing to the stagnation of social development among marginalized residents of Pakdasht and Qiyam-Dasht. The study population consists of individuals residing in the marginalized areas of Pakdasht and Qiyam-Dasht, who were purposively and theoretically sampled. In-depth individual interviews were conducted with 38 residents from these areas, with the criterion of theoretical saturation determining the termination of interviews. The data analysis followed the grounded theory method, employing the Straussian approach. The research findings reveal the causal conditions for the suspension of social development, including mutual irreversibility, transient and instrumental actions, weak self-concept, intergenerational perpetuation of poverty, and limited access to resources. Furthermore, the grounds contributing to the stagnation of social development manifest through categories such as divergent roles, gaps in social awareness, inadequate resource availability and reference groups, erosion of family boundaries, and institutional distrust. The outcomes illuminate that the mosaic structure of these regions has been shaped by ethnic conflicts and identity clashes. The dominance of ethnic pursuits, stemming from these conflicts and regressive ideologies, has hindered societal convergence. Furthermore, identity conflicts, exacerbated by profound inequalities, have impeded the adaptation of these ethnic groups to the modern world, particularly in the context of Tehran. Consequently, individuals in these areas tend to engage in transient and utilitarian actions, limiting the establishment of sustainable social interactions and impeding social development. Introduction Currently, within the realm of development, new themes have emerged that underscore the significance of people and their social capabilities. The prominence and position of social development as one of the four dimensions of development (including social, economic, cultural, and political dimensions) becomes evident when studying the progress of development theory and initiatives. This evolution represents a shift from a primary focus on economic aspects to encompass cultural and social dimensions. The emphasis on quantitative measures has been superseded by the concept of "human development" and a greater consideration of its comprehension and implementation. Theoretical and empirical advancements substantiate that social development is a pivotal element of development, characterized by inherent requisites. To achieve this, it necessitates governmental policy-making and planning, which are integral to the overall pursuit of development. Equally vital is the extent to which the society and its citizens (particularly marginalized populations) comprehend, embrace, and incorporate these policies and programs into their daily lives. This study sets out to address this latter aspect, aiming to gain insights into the social development dynamics among the marginalized residents of Pakdasht and Qiyamdasht areas. Specifically, it seeks to explore how the experiences of marginalization have influenced their understanding of social development and shaped their social actions within their daily lives. Employing a qualitative, deep, and comprehensive approach, this study will examine the social development among marginalized individuals, shedding light on diverse dimensions through an exploration of their lived experiences. Literature Review Prior research has extensively examined social development across various dimensions, including women's participation (Allen, 1985; Boland, 1987; Glicken, 1979; Thomas and Sina, 2009), education (Bradshaw and Graham, 2007; Resnik, 1997), local communities (Daly and Winter, 1978; Velosky and Monroe, 2009), and others. Moreover, several studies have addressed the assessment of social development rankings within Hamedan province's cities (Zofari et al., 2009), the examination of social development indicators and rankings across the country's provinces (Firouzabadi et al., 2010), the investigation into Iran's social development indicators and international position (Fazli et al., 2012), the exploration of human and social development indicators (Gay et al., 2017), the assessment of Iran's current social development status (Riahi, 2010), the examination of dimensions within social development theory (Jacobs and Cleveland, 2007), the identification of dimensions and components within the five development programs (Jaghtai et al., 2015), the analysis of social development in Tehran city (Asgharpour Masoleh et al., 2013), the adoption of a social development approach in poverty alleviation programs in Iran (Qanai-Rad, 2004), and the conceptualization and measurement of social development (Madani and Roshfekr, 2014), among others. Furthermore, there have been studies conducted by foreign and domestic researchers that focus on the perspective of marginalized individuals themselves. For instance, studies such as Martin's exploration in 2000 in Lima, Tupac, Perlman's investigation in 2010 in Argentina and Rio de Janeiro, Safa's analysis in 1974 in Puerto Rico, San Juan, Oiro's examination in 1988 in Argentina, Ghanem's study in 1997 in Cairo, Sharma's research in 1991 in Sarga, India, Piran's work in 1373, Ismaili and Omidi's inquiry in 2011 in Islamabad, Parsapzoh's study in 1381 in Islamabad, and Pereghi et al.'s investigation in 1383 in Isfahan provide valuable insights into the phenomenon of marginalization. It should be noted that unlike the aforementioned studies that primarily focused on social development, these studies delved into the complexities of marginalization. Methodology This scholarly research study employed a qualitative approach, adopting a data-based strategy. The targeted population consisted of all adult citizens aged 18 and above residing in the marginalized regions of Pak-Dasht and Qiyam-Dasht, from which a sampling process was implemented. It is worth noting that, based on information provided by the municipality and governorate, these regions encompass eight districts within the city of Pakdasht, while being limited to a single district in Qiyam-Dasht. However, it is important to highlight that the selection of interview participants was not solely based on the criteria set forth by the municipality and governorate. This is because certain locations, despite exhibiting characteristics associated with marginalization in social, economic, and physical terms, were not officially classified as such. Additionally, the researcher's understanding and identification of the extent of marginalization in specific cases differed from the mappings provided by official coordinates. To ensure a purposive and theoretical sampling, in-depth individual interviews were conducted with a total of 38 residents living in the aforementioned areas. Results This study delves into the bottlenecks of social development among marginalized communities, adopting an internal and micro-level perspective. The rapid growth of Pakdasht and Qiyam-Dasht has had profound impacts on the environmental and social dynamics of the region, manifesting in various forms. Particularly in Pakdasht, the presence of diverse ethnic groups contributes to the existence of distinct customs. However, due to the marginalized status of a significant portion of the population, these customs are not prominently observed. Consequently, a pervasive condition has emerged, characterized by income poverty, as well as social and cultural impoverishment. This predicament engenders insurmountable contradictions when confronted with the prevailing inequalities within the metropolis of Tehran. Daily life revolves primarily around livelihood pursuits and aspiring to attain essential societal values such as adequate housing, good health, and quality education. Unfortunately, these circumstances often undermine individuals' ability to engage in purposeful actions aimed at fostering a renewed sense of community and belonging within their place of residence. Moreover, the actions taken in this context are chiefly driven by individual rationality and economic cost-benefit considerations. Consequently, the social dimension is inadvertently sidelined, despite its pivotal role in shaping social development and the potential to establish new foundations for personal identity based on collective accomplishments. | ||
| Keywords | ||
| Social Development; Marginalized People; Generational Succession of Poverty; Limited Charity; Ethnic and Identity Conflict | ||
| References | ||
|
اسماعیلی، رضا و امیدی، مهدی. (1391)، «بررسی تجربه حاشیهنشینی از دیدگاه حاشیهنشینان»، مجله مطالعات جامعهشناختی شهری، دوره 2، شماره 3، صص 179-208.
اصغرپور ماسوله، روشنفکر، پیام و کلانتری، عبدالحسین. (۱۳۹۳)، توسعه اجتماعی در شهر تهران. تهران: انتشارات مرکز مطالعات و برنامهریزی شهر تهران.
ببیننده، مسعود.، محمودی، جهانگیر.، سنائی، علی. (1399). سیاستهای فضایی شهری و وضعیت محلههای فرودست. (اتنوگرافی نهادی محلههای آقازمان، قطارچیان، جورآباد و کورآباد شهر سنندج). جامعهشناسی فرهنگ و هنر، دوره 2، شماره 3، صص 26-48.
برهانی، کاظم.، رفیعیان، مجتبی.، مشکینی، ابوالفضل. (1396). تغییرات کاربری زمین شهری و اقتصاد سیاسی فضا: ارائه مدل مفهومی - تلفیقی. مجله جامعهشناسی ایران، دوره 18، شماره 3.
پارساپژوه، سپیده. (1381)، «نگرشی از درون به پدیده حاشیهنشینی مطالعه موردی: اسلامآباد کرج»، فصلنامه رفاه اجتماعی، شماره 6.
پیران، پرویز. (1366). آلونکنشینی در ایران. اطلاعات سیاسی-اقتصادی، شماره 6.
پیران، پرویز. (1374). آلونکنشینی در ایران. اطلاعات سیاسی-اقتصادی، شماره 91-96.
پیران، پرویز. (1387). از اسکان غیررسمی تا اسکان نایابی: در جستجوی راهحل. هفت شهر، دوره 2، شماره 23 و 24، صص 14-29.
پیران، پرویز. (1387)، «از اسکان غیررسمی تا اسکاننایابی (در جستجوی راهحل)»، مجله هفت شهر، شماره، شماره 23 و 24، صص 14- 30.
تاجبخش، غلامرضا. (1392)، «بررسی میزان سرمایه اجتماعی در بین حاشیهنشینان شهر ایلام»، مطالعات جامعهشناختی شهری، دوره 3، شماره 9، صص 123-97.
جاکبز، گری و کلولند، هارلن. (1387)، ابعاد نظریة توسعة اجتماعی، جمعی از مترجمان، تهران: پژوهشکده مطالعات فرهنگی و اجتماعی، صص 129- 177.
جغتائی، فائزه.، موسوی، میطاهر و زاهدی مازندرانی، محمدجواد. (1395)، «ابعاد و مؤلفههای توسعه اجتماعی در برنامههای توسعه»، فصلنامة علمی پژوهشی رفاه ا اجتماعی، سال شانزدهم، شماره 63.
رجبیگیلان، نادر.، قاسمی، سیدرامین.، رشادت، سهیلا.، زنگنه، علیرضا و سعیدی، شهرام. (1393). «سنجش کیفیت زندگی مرتبط با سلامت زنان ساکن در محلات حاشیهنشین شهر کرمانشاه و برخی عوامل مرتبط با آن»، ماهنامه علمی پژوهشی دانشگاه علوم پزشکی کرمانشاه، سال 18، شماره 9.
ریاحی، وحید. (1380)، «وضعیت فعلی جامعه ایران با نظر به شاخصهای توسعة اجتماعی»، مجموعه مقالات همایش توسعة اجتماعی، تهران: انتشارات علمی-فرهنگی.
شفیعا، سعید. (1389)، «رابطه ظرفیت اجتماعی ساکنان سکونتگاههای غیررسمی با توسعة پایدار محلهای»، پایاننامه کارشناسی ارشد دانشگاه علامه طباطبائی، دانشکده مدیریت و حسابداری.
ظفری، داریوش.، حسینی، محمدحسین.، خلیجی، محمدعلی.، فتحی، محمدحسین. (1389)، «رتبهبندی توسعة اجتماعی شهرستانهای استان همدان»، فصلنامه مطالعات جامعهشناختی، سال دوم، شماره هشتم، صص 129- 141.
عریضی، فروغ.، ربانی، رسول و کریمی، فاطمه. (1382)، «بررسی مسائل حاشیهنشینی با تأکید بر جنبههای اجتماعی فرهنگی. (مطالعه موردی مناطق ارزنان و دارکت اصفهان(»، علوم اجتماعی، دوره 10، شماره 24، صص 101-124.
فاضلی، محمد.، فتاحی، سجاد و زنجانرفیعی، سیدهنسترن. (۱۳۹۲)، توسعة اجتماعی، شاخصها و جایگاه ایران در جهان، مجله مطالعات توسعه اجتماعی فرهنگی، ۲. (۱)، ۱۸۲-۱۵۹.
فیروزآبادی، سیداحمد و همکاران. (1389)، «مطالعه شاخصها و رتبة توسعة اجتماعی در استانهای کشور و مقایسة آن با رتبةکشوری»، فصلنامة رفاه اجتماعی، سال دهم، شماره 37، صص 57-93.
قانعیراد، محمدامین. (1384)، رویکرد توسعة اجتماعی به برنامههای فقرزدایی در ایران»، فصلنامة رفاه اجتماعی، ویژهنامه فقر و نابرابری در ایران، شمارة 18.
گای، دارام و دیگران. (1377)، «بررسی شاخصهای انسانی و اجتماعی توسعه»، روستا و توسعه، شمارة چهارم.
محمدی، علیرضا و روستا، مجید. (1387)، «توسعة اجتماعمحور، سازوکاری برای ساماندهی سکونتگاههای غیررسمی»، مجله هفتشهر، شماره 23.
مدنی قهفرخی، سعید و روشنفکر، پیام. (۱۳۹۴). توسعه اجتماعی: مفهوم شناسی و سنجش. تهران: نشر بازتاب.
مؤمنی، فرشاد، امینیمیلانی، مینو. (1390)، «توانمندی و توسعه پایدار در برنامه سوم و چهارم توسعه ایران با رویکرد آمارتیاسن»، فصلنامه رفاه اجتماعی، دوره ۱۱، شماره ۴۲، صص ۳۷-۶۶.
نقدی، اسدالله و زارع، صادق. (1392)، «مطالعه نگرشها و رفتارهای اجتماعی - فرهنگی زنان حاشیهنشین (موردمطالعه: شهرک سعدی شیراز)»، مطالعات جامعهشناختی شهری، دوره 3، شماره 9، صص 67-96.
وصالی، سعید و قاسمینژاد، ابوذر. (1398)، «مطالعه دادهبنیاد حاشیهنشینی و توسعه اجتماعی، شناسایی شرایط مداخلهگر، راهبردها و پیامدهای تحققنیافتگی توسعه اجتماعی در بین حایهنشینان پاکدشت»، توسعه اجتماعی، دوره 14، شماره 2، صص 126-93.
References
Allen, J. A. V. (1985), Women as a major force in the planning and ‘Development Issues in Marginal Regions’. Taipei: National Taiwan University.
Boland, M. (1978). Women and poverty: Are they synonyms? Social Development Issues, 2 (3), 75-87.
Bradshaw, C. & Graham, J. R. (2007), Localization of social work practice, education, and research: A content analysis. Social Development Issues, 29 (2), 92-111.
Dahal, S. ; Sanjay K. Nepal , Michael A. Schuett (2014). 'Examining Marginalized Communities and Local Conservation Institutions: The Case of Nepal’s Annapurna Conservation Area, Environmental Management', 53:219–230.
Daley, J & Winter, T. (1978).Factors influencing the success of Peace Corps community development. Social Development Issues, 1(3), 55-72.
Daley, J & Winter, T. (1978).Factors influencing the success of Peace Corps community development. Social Development Issues, 1(3), 55-72.
Elden, S. (2004). Understanding Henri Lefebvre: Theory and the Possible (Continuum, London).
Healey, P. (1998), Building institutional capacity through collaborative approaches to urban planning, Environment and Planning A, Vol. 30.
Lefebvre, H. (1991). The Production of Space. Oxford: Blackwell.
Marsh, ch. (2000),Social capital and democracy in Russia, Communist and Post-Communist Studies 33(2):183-199.
McElroy M, Jorna RJ, van Engelen J. (2007) Sustainability Quotients and the Social Footprint, John Wiley and Sons Ltd and The European Research Press Ltd.
Razavi, m. and Iverson, l. (2006) ,'A grounded theory of information sharing behavior in a personal learning space', Banff, Alberta, Canada — November 04 - 08, 2006 ACM New York, NY, USA, Pp 459-468
Schmid, C. (2008). Henri Lefebvre’s theory of the production of space: Towards a three-dimensional dialectic. Space, difference, everyday life: reading Henri Lefebvre, 27-45.
Segnestam, L., Persson, A., Nilsson, M., Arvidsson,A., and Ijjasz, E. (2002), Country Environment Analysis: a Review of In ternational Experience, Environment Strategy Papers, No 8., World Bank.
Thomas, R. & Sinha, J. W. (2009).A critical look at microfinance and NGOs in regard to poverty reduction for women. Social Development Issues, 31(2), 30-42.
Vlosky, D. A. & Monroe, P. A. (2009). A study of participatory development in a community project in Honduras, Social Development Issues, 31(2), 70-85.
Zahra, K, Ather Ashraf, Tasneem Zafar, Bilal (2017), Marginality and Social Exclusion in Punjab, Pakistan: A Threat to Urban Sustainability, Sustainable Cities and Society https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2017.11.009.
References [In Persian]
Esmaili, Reza and Omidi, Mehdi (2013), "Examining the experience of marginalization from the point of view of marginalization", Journal of Urban Sociological Studies, Volume 2, Number 3, pp. 179-208.. [In Persian]
Asgharpour Masuleh, intellectual, Payam and Kalantari, Abdul Hossein (2013), Social Development in Tehran. Tehran: Publications of Tehran City Studies and Planning Center. [In Persian]
The viewer, Masoud; Mahmoudi, Jahangir; Sanai, Ali (2019). Urban Spatial Policies and the Status of Subordinate Neighborhoods (Institutional Ethnography of Aghazaman, Terechian, Jorabad and Korabad Neighborhoods in Sanandaj City). Sociology of culture and art, volume 2, number 3, pp. 26-48.. [In Persian]
Burhani, Kazem; Rafiyan, Mojtaba; Meshkini, Alwalfazl (2016). Changes in urban land use and the political economy of space: presenting a conceptual-integrated model. Iranian Journal of Sociology, Volume 18, Number 3.. [In Persian]
Parsapjoh, Sepideh (2008), "An insider's view of the phenomenon of marginalization, a case study: Islamabad Karaj", Social Welfare Quarterly, No. 6.. [In Persian]
Piran, Parviz (1366). Lodging in Iran. Political-Economic Information, No. 6.. [In Persian]
Piran, Parviz (1374). Lodging in Iran. Political-Economic Information, No. 91-96.. [In Persian]
Piran, Parviz (2007). From informal settlement to rare settlement: in search of a solution. Seven cities, volume 2, numbers 23 and 24, pp. 14-29.. [In Persian]
Piran, Parviz (2007), "From informal housing to scarce housing (in search of a solution)", Haft Shahr magazine, No. 23 and 24, pp. 14-30.. [In Persian]
Tajbakhsh, Gholamreza (2012), "Investigating the amount of social capital among the marginal residents of Ilam city", Urban Sociological Studies, Volume 3, Number 9, pp. 97-123.. [In Persian]
Jacobs, Gary and Cleveland, Harlan (2007), The theoretical dimensions of social development, a group of translators, Tehran: Research Institute of Cultural and Social Studies, pp. 177-129.. [In Persian]
Joghatai, Faezeh; Mousavi, Mitaher and Zahedi Mazandarani, Mohammad Javad (2015), "Dimensions and components of social development in development programs", Social welfare research quarterly, 16th year, number 63.. [In Persian]
Rajabi Gilan, Nader; Ghasemi, Sidramin; Rashad, Sohaila; Zanganeh, Aireza and Saidi, Shahram (2014). "Measuring the health-related quality of life of women living in the marginal areas of Kermanshah city and some factors related to it", scientific research monthly of Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences, year 18, number 9. [In Persian]
Riahi, Vahid (1380), "The current state of Iranian society with regard to social development indicators", collection of articles of social development conference, Tehran: Scientific-Cultural Publications [In Persian].
Shafia, Saeed (1389), "The relationship between the social capacity of residents of informal settlements and the sustainable development of neighborhoods", Master's thesis of Allameh Tabatabai University, Faculty of Management and Accounting. [In Persian]
Zafari, Dariush; Hosseini, Mohammad Hossein; Khalji, Mohammad Ali; Fathi, Mohammad Hossein (1389), "Ranking of social development of the cities of Hamedan province", Sociological Studies Quarterly, second year, number eight, pp. 129-141. [In Persian]
Erehi, Forough; Rabbani, Rasool and Karimi, Fatemeh (2012), "Investigation of marginalization issues with emphasis on social and cultural aspects (case study of Arznan and Darket areas of Isfahan"), Social Sciences, Volume 10, Number 24, pp. 101-124.. [In Persian]
Fazli, Mohammad; Fatahi, Sajjad and Zanjan-Rafiei, Seyed-Nastern (2019), Social Development, Indicators and Iran's Place in the World, Journal of Social and Cultural Development Studies, 2(1), 159-182.. [In Persian]
Firouzabadi, Sidahmad et al. (2008), "Study of social development indicators and rank in the country's provinces and comparing it with the national rank", Social Welfare Quarterly, Year 10, No. 37, pp. 57-93.. [In Persian]
Qaneirad, Mohammad Amin (2004), social development approach to poverty alleviation programs in Iran", Social Welfare Quarterly, Special Issue on Poverty and Inequality in Iran, No18.. [In Persian]
Guy, Daram and others (1377), "Review of human and social indicators of development", Village and Development, No4.. [In Persian]
Mohammadi, Alireza and Rusta, Majid (2007), "Community-oriented development, a mechanism for organizing informal settlements", Haft Shahr magazine, number 23.. [In Persian]
Madani Qahfarkhi, Saeed and Roshanfekr, Payam (2014). Social Development: Conceptualization and Measurement. Tehran: Reflection publication. [In Persian]
Momeni, Farshad, Amini-Milani, Mino (2018), "Empowerment and sustainable development in the third and fourth development plans of Iran with the Amartiasen approach", Social Welfare Quarterly, Volume 11, Number 42, pp. 66-37.. [In Persian]
Naqdi, Asadullah and Zare, Sadegh (2012), "Study of socio-cultural attitudes and behaviors of marginalized women (Study case: Saadi town of Shiraz)", Urban Sociological Studies, Volume 3, Number 9, pp. 67-96 .. [In Persian]
Wasali, Saeed and Ghasemi-Nejad, Abuzar (2018), "data-based study of marginalization and social development, identification of intervening conditions, strategies and consequences of non-realization of social development among the residents of Pakdasht", social development, Volume 14, Number 2, pp. 93-126. [In Persian]
استناد به این مقاله: قاسمینژاد، ابوذر.، شبستر، محسن.، اسماعیلزاده، علیاصغر. (1402). تنگناهای توسعه اجتماعی در بین حاشیهنشینان (مطالعه دادهبنیاد شرایط علی و زمینهای در بین حاشیهنشینان پاکدشت و قیامدشت)، فصلنامه برنامهریزی توسعه شهری و منطقهای، 8(27)، 203 -2473.
DOI: 10.22054/URDP.2023.70792.1495
Urban and Regional Development Planning is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License... | ||
|
Statistics Article View: 1,403 PDF Download: 473 |
||