- All Journals
- Communication Sciences
- ECO College of Insurance
- Economics
- Law and Political Sciences
- Management and Accounting
- Persian Literature and Foreign Languages
- Physical Education and Sport Sciences
- Psychology and Education
- Research
- Social Sciences
- Statistics, Mathematics, and Computer
- Theology and Islamic Studies
News
Realization of a fair trial in quasi-judicial authorities (Dispute Resolution Council) | ||
| پژوهش حقوق خصوصی | ||
| Volume 10, Issue 38, March 2022, Pages 97-126 PDF (587.82 K) | ||
| Document Type: Research Paper | ||
| DOI: 10.22054/jplr.2022.61878.2591 | ||
| Authors | ||
| Hashem Farhadi* 1; Ahma Shams2 | ||
| 1PhD student in private law, Islamic Azad University-South Tehran | ||
| 2Associate Professor, Islamic Azad University, South Tehran Branch | ||
| Abstract | ||
| Achieving a fair trial and ensuring justice in the trial is initially subject to identifying the principles governing the trial and adapting it to the principles and rules of the national and transnational legal system and adapting it to the circumstances prevailing in each judicial authority. As a quasi-judicial authority with a conciliatory approach and compromise, on the one hand, the deliberations of the council in accordance with the laws and regulations are not subject to the procedures and principles of the trial, and on the other hand, the deliberations of the council in terms of principles and rules are subject to the rules of civil and criminal procedure. Due to the absence of the judge in the council meeting, this issue causes inconsistencies and conflicts in the issuance of the verdict. Sub-vote is the result of the review process and in practice the council judge does not play a key role in it. Therefore, in order to comply with the rules and principles of procedure, it is necessary to separate the issues raised in the council in terms of compromise and compensation from the beginning. Compromise issues without observing the court proceedings by the members of the council and dispute issues with the presence of the council judge in the hearing in accordance with the principles of the court and the governing procedures to be considered in order to achieve a fair trial in practice in this judicial authority. Keywords: Judicial Authority, Dispute Resolution Council, Fair Trial | ||
| Keywords | ||
| Fair Trial"; Dispute Resolution Council "; Quasi-Judicial Authority"; Compromise "; Adversarial | ||
| References | ||
|
Abdali, Mehrzad, civil procedure procedure and procedure, first edition (Tehran: Nik Andish Publications, 2015). Taziknejad, Ali; Shafiei Sardasht, Jafar, "Tax Procedure in Iran", Legal Researches, No. 10 (2015), pp. 367. Office of Research and Studies of the Ministry of Justice, the collection of advisory opinions of the Legal Department in the field of civil issues, (Tehran: Office of Research and Studies of the Ministry of Justice, Bita). Rezainejad, Amirhossein, civil procedure and normal ways of complaining about votes, first edition (Tehran: Nash Andishgaran, 2019). Shahidi, Musa, judicial standards (Publisher: Scientific Press, 1340). Shams, Abdullah, "Principle of Correspondence", Journal of Legal Research, No. 35 and 36 (2012), pp. 61. Shams, Abdullah, Code of Civil Procedure, Volume 3, Edition (Tehran: Mizan Publications: 1380). Sadrzadeh Afshar, Seyyed Mohsen, Civil and Commercial Procedures, fifth edition (Tehran: Majd Publications, 1378). Ghamami, Majid; Mohseni, ???, Principles of Transnational Procedure, first edition (Tehran: Mizan Publications, 2016). Qolipour, Hassan; Ahmadi, Seyyed Mehdi; Jafari Metekalai, Mohammad Hassan, "Investigation of the principle of proportionality (correspondence) in judicial proceedings and international commercial arbitration", Islamic Jurisprudence and Law Research Quarterly, 10th year, 37th issue (2013), pp. 130 and 131. Matin Daftari, Ahmed, Code of Civil and Commercial Procedure, Volume 2, First Edition (Tehran: Majid Publications, 1378). Moin, Mohammad, Farhang Farsi, Volume 1, 4th edition, (Tehran: Amirkabir Publications, 1360). Moezenzadegan, Hassan Ali, Lectures on Criminal Procedure 2, Bachelor of Laws, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, Allameh Tabatabai University, (2006). Mohajeri, Ali; Pourarab, Reza, Absentee Ruling in Islamic Jurisprudence and Iranian Law, first edition (Tehran: Khat Som Publishing, 2001). The collection of judicial views of Tehran province judiciary, volume 2, (Tehran: Dadyar Publishing House, December 2010). Mohajeri, Ali, Description of the Code of Civil Procedure, Volume 2 (Tehran: Ganj Danesh Publications,
| ||
|
Statistics Article View: 531 PDF Download: 345 |
||