Umbrella Clause in Bilateral Investment Treaties

Oloumi Yazdi, Hamid Reza; Mohammadi, Somayeh

Obtaining a ranking by the journal of education leadership research from the Ministry of Science, Research and Technology

Obtaining the "A" rating by the Quranic Knowledge Research Journal from the Ministry of Science, Research and Technology

Consultative meeting of officials of scientific journals of Allameh Tabatabai University

The scientific evaluation results of the journals of Allameh Tabataba'i University in the year 1401; 18 titles succeeded in obtaining an "A" rank.

	Umbrella Clause in Bilateral Investment Treaties
پژوهش حقوق عمومی
Article 2, Volume 16, Issue 43, February 2015, Pages 47-80 PDF (437.28 K)
Document Type: Research Paper
Authors
hamid reza oloumi yazdi; somayeh mohammadi
Abstract
The Umbrella Clause has nearly become one of the most common rules of the most investment treaties, which provides more protections for foreign investor. Providing a proper and true sense of this clause has become highly controversial issue in international investment law that has led many arbitral tribunals to adopt specific stance in this respect. Here, the fundamental point is whether the forum stipulated in the bilateral investment treaty is competent to settle disputes, which are arisen from investment contract between host State and foreign investor, or not? If it so, then the next question would be: what will be the effect of the determining the forum by stipulated dispute settlement clause in the contract. Does this clause turn contract claims into the treaty claims? And what will be the impacts and limits of this clause? Answering to these questions, the arbitral tribunals have responded in two different ways. Some of them have interpreted the clause in a narrow sense; they have distinguished sovereign from non-sovereign act of host State. According to their point of view, the Umbrella Clause of BIT may be violated if the host State measure, in breaching its contractual obligation, is applied on the basis of its sovereignty. In contrast, the other tribunals have interpreted this clause in a broad sense which the violation of any contractual obligation of host State leads to a breach of this clause and consequently the forum in the investment treaty is qualified to hear the dispute. It seems that the broad interpretation and second approach is more logical in the interpretation of the clause; it is also more consistent with the purpose and history of the emergence of this clause and makes it more efficient.
Keywords
Umbrella Clause; Bilateral investment treaty; Investment contracts; Sovereign act; Non-sovereign act; ICSID Arbitral Tribunal; Jurisdiction competence; Interpretation of treaties

References
- Potts, Jonathan, “Stabilizing the Role of Umbrella Clauses in Bilateral Investment Treaties: Intent, Reliance, and Internationalization” (2011) (No. 4) Virjinia Journal of International Law, Vol. 51. - Ethan G. Shenkman & D. Jason File, “Recent Development in Investment Treaty Jurisprudence: Arbitrating Contract Claims under Umbrella Clauses”, available at: www.wilmerhale.com/files/publications/9cd84cee-3ded-91a4-da 85702872/ presentationattachment/shenkmanfile2007_intlarb.pdf. - Gautam, Pradhuman, “The Umbrella clause: A Search for Greater Legal Certainty”, 25/08/2008, p. 12, available at: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/delivery. cfm/ ssrn. - Reinisch,August, “Umbrella Clauses”,(2006) ,Seminar on International Investment Protection (OECD). - Schill, Stephan, “ Enabling Private Ordering: Function, Scope and Effect of Umbrella Clauses in International Investment traeties” (2009) (No.1), Minnesota Journal of International Law, Vol.18. - Schwebel, Stephan, “On Whether the Breach by a State of a Contract with an Alien Is a Breach of International Law” (1987), International Law at the Time of Its Codification. - Shany, Yuval, “Contract Claims v. Treaty Claims: Mapping Conflicts between ICSID Decisions on Multisourced Investment Cases” (2005), American Journal of International Law, Vol.99. - Shawcross, Hartley William, “The Problems of Forein Investment in International Law” (1961) (No. 1),Recueil Des Cours, Vol. 102. - Sinclair, Anthony C., “The Origin of Umbrella Clauses in International Law of Investment Protection” (2004) (No. 4), Arbitration International, Vol. 20. - Walde, Thomas, “Umbrella Clause in Investment Arbitration” (2005) (N.183), The Journal Of Worlde Investment & Trade, V.6. - آرای داوری - CMS Gas Transmission Co. v. Argentine Republic, ICSID Case No. ARB/01/8, Decision on Annulment, available at: http://icsid.worldbank.org/ icsid/frontservlet, 2011/02/12. Consortium RFCC v. Morocco, ICSID Case No. ARB/00/6, Award, available at: http://icsid.worldbank.org/icsid/frontservlet, 2011/02/12. - El Paso Energy v. Argentine Republic, ICSID Case No, ARB/03/15, Decision on Jurisdiction, available at: http://icsid.worldbank.org/icsid/frontservlet, 2011/02/12. - Eureko B.V. v. Republic of Poland, Ad Hoc Investment Treaty Case, Partial Award, available at: http://icsid.worldbank.org/icsid/frontservlet ,2011/02/12. - Fedex N.V. v. Republic of Venezuela, ICSID Case No. ARB/96/3, Award, available at: http://icsid.worldbank.org/icsid/frontservlet,2011/02/12. - Joy Minig Machinery Limited v. Egypt, ICSID Case No. ARB/03/11, Decision on Jurisdiction, available at:http://icsid.worldbank.org/icsid/ frontservlet. - LG & E Energy Corp. v. Argentine Republic, ICSID Case No. ARB/02/1, Decision on Liabality, available at: http://icsid.worldbank.org/icsid/ frontservlet, 2011/02/12. - Noble Venture Inc. v. Romania, ICSID Case No. ARB/ 01/11, Award, available at: http://icsid.worldbank.org/icsid/frontservlet,2011/02/12. - Pan American Energy LLC v. Argentine R epublic, ICSID Case No. ARB/03/13, Decision on Preliminary Objections, available at: http://icsid.worldbank.org/icsid/ frontservlet,2011/02/12. - Sempra Eergy nrnational v. Argentine, ICSID Case No. ARB/02/16, Decision on Objections to Jurisdiction, available at: http://icsid.worldbank.org/icsid/ frontservlet,2011/02/12. - SGS v. Islamic Republic of Pakistan, ICSID Case No. ARB/01/13, Decision on Objections to Jurisdiction, available at: http:// icsid.worldbank. org/ icsid/ frontservlet,2011/02/12. - SGS v. Republic of the Philippines, ICSID Case No. ARB/02/06, Decision on Objections to Jurisdiction, available at: http://icsid.worldbank.org/ icsid/ frontservlet, 2011/02/12.
Statistics Article View: 4,605 PDF Download: 3,136

Related Links

News

Umbrella Clause in Bilateral Investment Treaties